Grocery

Sourced from small makers and purveyors with the highest quality and sustainability standards.

Abundantly Good Colby

8oz block
Third Wheel Cheese
$6.49
Add to cart

Abundantly Good Jalepeño Colby

8oz block
Third Wheel Cheese
$6.49
Add to cart

Abundantly Good Sharp Cheddar

8oz block
Third Wheel Cheese
$6.49
Add to cart

Abundantly Good Smoked Cheddar

8oz block
Third Wheel Cheese
$6.49
Add to cart
Sale Almond Butter - Organic

Almond Butter - Organic

14oz jar
Enzo Oilve Oil Company
$14.99
Add to cart
Sale Apple Butter

Apple Butter

9 oz.
Three Springs Fruit Farm
$4.99
Add to cart

Apple Ginger Butter

9 oz.
Three Springs Fruit Farm
$4.99
Add to cart

Apple Juice - Fuji

32 oz. jar
Three Springs Fruit Farm
$5.99
Add to cart

Apple Sauce

25 oz.
Three Springs Fruit Farm
$4.99
Add to cart

Bath Salts - Cherry Wooder Ice

10oz glass jar
Vellum St. Soap Company
$24.99
Add to cart
Sale BBQ Sauce - Original

BBQ Sauce - Original

18oz jar
Bill's Best Original BBQ Sauces
$6.99
Add to cart

BBQ Sauce - Spicy

18oz jar
Bill's Best Original BBQ Sauces
$6.99
Add to cart

Birchrun Hills Blue

5oz wedge
Third Wheel Cheese
$8.99/lb. Avg. 4.8 oz.
Add to cart

Black Garlic

3oz bag
Mad Dog Farm
$6.49
Add to cart

Blueberry Pie Ice Cream

Pint
Harper's Ice Cream
$9.99
Add to cart
Sale Brioche Loaf, Gluten-Free - Frozen

Brioche Loaf, Gluten-Free - Frozen

1 loaf
Flakely Gluten Free
$16.99
Add to cart

Buns, Sweet Potato

4 pk
Philly Bread
$4.49
Add to cart

Butter - Salted

1/2 pound roll
Oasis at Bird-in-Hand
$7.49
Add to cart

Butter - Unsalted

1/2 pound roll
Oasis at Bird-in-Hand
$7.49
Add to cart

Buttermilk - Organic

Pint
Oasis at Bird-in-Hand
$2.99
Add to cart

Calkins Creamery Noblette Brie - Full Wheel

10oz round
Third Wheel Cheese
$22.99
Add to cart

Calkins Creamery Noblette Brie - Half Wheel

5oz half round
Third Wheel Cheese
$12.49
Add to cart

Candle (Tallow & Beeswax) - Blood Orange Bergamot

Vellum St. Soap Company
$35.99
Sold Out

Candle (Tallow & Beeswax) - Cherry Wooder Ice

Vellum St. Soap Company
$35.99
Add to cart

Canned Peaches

28 oz.
Three Springs Fruit Farm
$5.49
Add to cart

Caramelized Banana Pudding Ice Cream

Pint
Harper's Ice Cream
$9.99
Add to cart

Chocolate Bar - Sea Salt and Thai Long Pepper 73% Dark Chocolate

2.1 oz bar
Shane's Confectionery
$8.99
Add to cart

Chocolate Bar - 42% Milk Chocolate

2.1 oz bar
Shane's Confectionery
$7.99
Add to cart

Chocolate Bar - 68.5% Dark Chocolate

2.1 oz bar
Shane's Confectionery
$7.99
Sold Out

Chocolate Bar - Bluecoat White Chocolate

2.1 oz bar
Shane's Confectionery
$8.99
Add to cart
Sale Chocolate Salted Bacon Brownie

Chocolate Salted Bacon Brownie

Primal Supply Meats
$4.99
Sold Out

Cinnamon Raisin Loaf

Philly Bread
$6.49
Add to cart

Cinnamon Raisin Loaf - Frozen

Philly Bread
Sale $1.50 savings
$6.49 $4.99
Add to cart

Clover Creek Royer Moutain

8oz wedge
Third Wheel Cheese
Sale $2.00 savings
$13.99 $11.99
Add to cart

Coffee, Whole Bean - Revolver Blend

12 oz. bag
Rival Bros. Coffee Roasters
$13.99
Add to cart
Sale Coffee, Whole Bean - Whistle & Cuss

Coffee, Whole Bean - Whistle & Cuss

12 oz. bag
Rival Bros. Coffee Roasters
$13.99
Add to cart

Conebella Cheese Curds

8oz container
Conabella Farm
Sale $2.00 savings
$7.99 $5.99
Add to cart

Conebella Fresh Mozzarella

15oz round
Conabella Farm
$15.49
Add to cart

Conebella Sharp Cheddar

8oz block
Conabella Farm
$7.99
Add to cart

Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

Pint
Harper's Ice Cream
$9.99
Add to cart

Cracker - Everything

6oz bag
Rip Rap Baking
$5.99
Add to cart

Cracker - Parmesan Rye

6oz bag
Rip Rap Baking
$5.99
Add to cart

Cracker - Sea Salt

6oz bag
Rip Rap Baking
$5.99
Add to cart

Cream - Organic

Pint
Oasis at Bird-in-Hand
$6.50
Add to cart

Crushed Tomatoes

28 oz can
First Field
$5.49
Add to cart

Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

5oz
Cape May Peanut Butter Co.
$6.49
Add to cart

Dark Chocolate Pretzel

Shane's Confectionery
$5.25
Add to cart

De-Glae Sheep Lanchego

8oz wedge
Lancaster Farm Fresh
$17.99
Add to cart

Dew Drop Sheep's Milk Camembert

6 oz round
Lancaster Farm Fresh
$14.99
Add to cart

Dry Beans - Jacob's Cattle

16 oz bag
Zone 7
$7.99
Add to cart

Dry Beans - Kidney Beans

16 oz bag
Zone 7
$4.99
Add to cart

Dry Beans - Yellow Eye

16 oz bag
Zone 7
$7.99
Add to cart

Dry Black - Black Beans

16 oz bag
Zone 7
$4.99
Add to cart

Dulce De Leche Ice Cream

Pint
Harper's Ice Cream
$9.99
Add to cart

Eggs - Chicken

One dozen
Primal Supply Meats
$6.00
Add to cart

Eggs - Duck

1/2 dozen
Primal Supply Meats
Sale $1.00 savings
$4.00 $3.00
Add to cart

Farro Miso

9oz jar
Keepwell Vinegar
$14.99
Add to cart

Flour - Bread Flour, Sifted/AP, Beiler's Heritage Acres

2lb. bag
Zone 7
$7.99
Add to cart

Flour - Organic White All Purpose

5lb. bag
Small Valley Milling
$15.99
Add to cart

Flour - Organic White Wheat Bread

5lb. bag
Small Valley Milling
$15.99
Sold Out

Flour - Organic Whole Wheat All Purpose

5lb. bag
Small Valley Milling
$15.99
Add to cart

Flour - Whole Wheat Bread, Farmer Ground

2lb. bag
Zone 7
$8.99
Add to cart

Focaccia

4 pk
Philly Bread
$5.99
Sold Out

Focaccia - Frozen

4 pk
Philly Bread
Sale $1.50 savings
$5.99 $4.49
Add to cart

Fresh Cracked Fennel Radiatori - Frozen

1 lb. bag
Little Noodle Pasta Co.
$6.99
Add to cart

Fresh Rigatoni - Frozen

1 lb. bag
Little Noodle Pasta Co.
$6.99
Add to cart

Goat Rodeo Fresh Chevre

6oz tub
Third Wheel Cheese
$10.99
Add to cart

Goat Rodeo Wild Rosemary

4-8oz wedge
Third Wheel Cheese
$30.99/lb. Avg. 6 oz.
Add to cart
Sale Gochujang

Gochujang

9oz jar
Keepwell Vinegar
$14.99
Add to cart

Granola - Maple Almond

12oz bag
Lancaster Farm Fresh
$10.99
Add to cart

Granola Bar - Dark Chocolate Sea Salt

3oz bar
Lancaster Farm Fresh
$4.49
Add to cart

Grits, Yellow

2lb. bag
$10.99
Add to cart

Half & Half - Organic

Pint
Oasis at Bird-in-Hand
$4.25
Add to cart

Harissa Paste

10oz jar
NY Shuk
$12.99
Add to cart

Hidden Hills Old Gold

4-8oz wedge
Third Wheel Cheese
$26.99/lb. Avg. 5.6 oz.
Sold Out
Sale Hoisin - Sweet Potato

Hoisin - Sweet Potato

9oz jar
Keepwell Vinegar
$14.99
Add to cart

Honey - Wildflower (large)

1lb jar
Mill Creek Apiary
$13.99
Add to cart

Honey Lemon Thyme Ice Cream

Pint
Harper's Ice Cream
$9.99
Add to cart
Sale Hot Sauce - Apple Wood Smoked Poblano

Hot Sauce - Apple Wood Smoked Poblano

5oz bottle
Whitehouse Station Sauce Co.
$7.99
Add to cart
Sale Hot Sauce - Habanero

Hot Sauce - Habanero

5oz bottle
Whitehouse Station Sauce Co.
$7.99
Add to cart
Return To Top
Privacy Policy